RetroShare certs

[sierrafox]
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[nimiridian]

CQEGAcOkxsFNBF+rUTEBEAD1OvqQwFBe3pGAJUmDKqMsPuSVzxnCQR1BpPu1WxhA
ilS/sRwwGv243sYABB/69Zcr4C6CdjsRrM0beSOTNmxiix/5+7+Ml4EPKGA6T66E
KFuzDNhzi5/vv7cAqGOSt3hM5WH65GIo4Av5BlH1bMMfOERSLI4QFw1TK7zVo7/t
jLwOUIMMCY8sjus+9P/8pe0F2b/JMijYFlqEW03Wc4XDSu98cyEcdK0ffgX3fUXs
a6IzHuOMsHEAUmfStgVrl1CesgA96wRo9O+WxrXPoqIZlUOnxm3wTAWnHXt7Q+wi
xHxzpmkO38CRVvs0AUHLJWWCckNZrCeZ3OkMuCvM5oHWKjo+yCrEd2P65iH2mnmE
Fpnx3dYrlFIr/frcc7WjaIMZc3bpfRnGM+/UwL/sXjyxN0OEOb3n+paH2qHD4bCI
ibuWXHzxad+GnEfLTd+1ft7wrK/maVeJK5D+iiX2gRuF/1LFqRgPV/lV14wxuF6N
NJ4JoREdG9S0/SkqmoV0h9APJp35Jr3N77QvKHotMez6Kx5VB5c9kih/UYxvGOFp
o+j2WNL2fPwS/pqnzzm3iE/Kk20goT2M8CsQNuEWFnLg0tDClmzACMj6KkVZeB37
prxjdPyrtrDeI2jhva2QUrCKQD+jI+t+K3A7RC8j7vQW//ZeAhppWiKI/3p0XnnD
sQARAQABzTBDeW5pY2FsVmVsb2NpdHkxMTU2IChHZW5lcmF0ZWQgYnkgUmV0cm9T
aGFyZSkgPD7CwV8EEwECABMFAl+rUTEJEKcN9V5hcOivAhkBAAA4ig//RmdRdyvV
4ShkiqqP6+VwwaI46/us3kTQjMaGFoRc97mh+0HWlU5k2oJ+N4eUOUmH6yyxEYkE
7NfwaLj3jx416Fn2ADhUrmnX9AtgyZzRY0U+2M/MiqQAwqdkCwRrTzKx2QfdMi7G
jBdL2jFxLkORF6c2GG+pS8wOyaDegeRXsGZm70oSv5QVf4kjmKmE9y28TQv0nLxN
zEhqy26OPU0HSeHWu0DnOS19lYGwFuD3gMJJczsyDKTF6tJiWQGW2OArMGA0/yxH
5KYOx0PDXisMJOmsJIZERix2RcrW2DjWe7g1Y/1mfZErzawanPZHok88nDUJjaPF
o+ZO1zNxviSzv7nMrJRrBAeJ1Ghzfj02ED9ahuZ0C7QoGBhRD2ovlGyLpBV1OAX7
gTObwbHoRodJXzgvz9iOLbOCIrQY81mF58M1pZc/WIaBDBXl0A07y/YSPPG1LAMC
B03bJf/A1XGtDDZSvwvwGPMDW0Mo8X4VkJPEl7L1gtyH13nf4ceFegcOu+9UXQxt
34mB0sbrkVd8NMfWCY7Ix6CMURqoB9E6GpBm7e3pZp09VG5NXqL1vc2zERdWWC/A
bI5fQdvI+mav5Sud213C6Oq+xT4iY5DhznAD2LYjL5y1Ullvx1jTo+41V2Iyl1ZK
l53pHcz0t6PoV0aEDMWgTFYi2ZzgqLvLBGgIG3JiN3I3aTJ0eW11N3lvNzMub25p
b246OTg3OAYHRGVmYXVsdAUQX6z9UnaWkCaOjpSojaAYkwcDbUrU

[batmetal4000]
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[goon98]
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[sentinel]
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[jacksonsurf37]
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[Hypno_J]

Some stats:
This thread has 443 post, most of them are certificates.

~90 of them connected during the last 30 days (~15 of them are not sharing anything),
including ~80 who connected during the last 14 days,
including ~60 who connected during the last 7 days.

Fact: people who didn't connect during the last 14 days will most likely never connect again.
(Stats are very approximate because I have also added a few people from other places.)

[Like Ra]

people who didn't connect during the last 14 days will most likely never connect again.

Not quite - think of vacations, business travels, exams, crashes, reinstalls, migrations, etc. 14 days is not that long.

Some people turn RS/torrent on only if they need to download something.That's the problem indeed...

[Hypno_J]

people who didn't connect during the last 14 days will most likely never connect again.

Not quite - think of vacations, business travels, exams, crashes, reinstalls, migrations, etc. 14 days is not that long.

No, those people are only a small minority. It's not an opinion or a guess, that's what I'm seeing on my Retroshare according to the connection dates. There are only a few people in the range 15-30 days. And I would say ~95% of people who didn't connect for 30 days never connected after 3 months either. I can see it, because I tag them differently.

Of course there are some exceptions, that's why I said "most likely". But among those who didn't connect in the last 15 days most of them actually only connected a few times, then moved on to something else. And that is confirmed by the fact that the majority of certificates in the thread are not connecting anymore at all, as I see on Retroshare (not a guess). But the software isn't very reliable as I have seen (1 or 2 times) people 'connected 5 days ago' while they are actively downloading at the same time, so maybe some other people see it differently.

Some people turn RS/torrent on only if they need to download something.That's the problem indeed...

Exactly.
People don't stay connected and they don't mirror full collections, they only take what they need (and especially some S4manth4 😊 ). And when some big sharers sometime leave the community and move on to something else, I see files literally disappearing from the community.

Logically a sharing network can only stay alive and expand if there is an incentive to share, implemented right into the sharing system. That's aeady the case with torrents for trackers with a sharing ratio (but the problem is it's centralized, and sometimes difficult to get ratio without a seedbox, and doesn't address the fact that only popular torrents stay alive). Some cryptocurrencies have also solved the issue with "Proof of Stake" because they need the nodes to remain online.

For Retroshare there is few hope of a change because original developers have left the project since a long time, and current developers don't want to mess with things and are only changing cosmetic stuffs on the interface.
There is a newer software called Fopnu created by the former developers of WinMX, it's better than Retroshare in every aspects (no need to share certificates, bandwidth is not wasted by search forwarding, the software itself is more stable, it's looks better...), but the main critical problem is exactly the same... there is no incentive to share. And that's why their sharing network is empty, and people don't mirror collections and don't stay connected. I have posted a feature request to address the problem on their support forum but never got an answer.
Now we can only hope that some day, someone will have the skills and the time and the interest to develop a sharing software with sharing incentive as a central priority. 😊

[vesahec]
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